The HCFO program ended in December 2016.
This site will no longer be updated, and some elements may not appear correctly.
As a wise Greek philosopher once noted, the only thing constant is change. One exciting change for the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation is the movement towards building a Culture of Health in America, with a new emphasis on investments that promote health beyond the medical system to places where people live, learn, work, and play. While this means we will wind down the Changes in Health Care Financing and Organization (HCFO) program, the contributions of HCFO-funded research will certainly endure. During the upcoming year, staff will focus its efforts on dissemination and convening, using findings from ongoing and past studies to help inform the work of policymakers and health care leaders.
HCFO’s activities in 2014 addressed a variety of topics, including innovations in insurance markets and benefit design, pay for performance and other issues in provider payment, Affordable Care Act (ACA) implementation, and virtual physician visits.
Supporting Researchers
Grantmaking
The five grants funded in 2014 address some of the most pressing health policy issues, including the role of private exchanges within the unfolding ACA environment and continuing strategies to engage consumers and control health care costs.
- Investigating Physician Adaptation and Response to Financial Incentives to Improve Performance, Timothy Hoff, Ph.D. and Gary Young, J.D., Ph.D., Northeastern University
- Private Health Insurance Exchanges: Prospects and Problems, Mark A. Hall, J.D., Wake Forest University Health Sciences
- Impact of Increased Cost Sharing on Utilization of Low-Value Services: The First Evaluation of this Approach Nationally, Johanna Catherine Maclean, Ph.D., Temple University
- The Impact of Reference Pricing on Consumer Choice and Provider Pricing for Laboratory Tests and Diagnostic Imaging, James C. Robinson, Ph.D., Regents of the University of California
- Impact of New Medicare Readmissions Policy on Hospital Readmissions for All Patients, David Zingmond, M.D., Ph.D., Regents of the University of California, Los Angeles
Special Topic Solicitations
Six grants were funded in early December 2013 following a special topic solicitation, Understanding the Impact of Price Data in Health Care. During the past year, HCFO staff have connected the grantees with federal policymakers and other relevant stakeholders interested in advancing the transparency of the health care system. These connections are designed to ensure that the researchers address the most pressing policy questions and that the end-users of the research are aware of the work and upcoming findings.
Working in collaboration with the team at SHADAC, on January 13, 2014, HCFO released a RWJF special topic solicitation, State Health Access Reform Evaluation: Coverage Provisions of the Affordable Care Act. The solicitation was designed to solicit studies examining the implementation of the ACA in states and/or the impact of the ACA on coverage, health care utilization, and affordability. Researchers submitted 113 brief proposals from which 23 full proposals were invited. Ten grants were funded in October 2014.
Webinars
We believe strongly in our commitment to supporting the field, including professional development offerings for new and established researchers. Our webinars are designed to disseminate the work of HCFO-funded researchers and provide information on the use of traditional and new data sources and tools important to research on health care financing and organization topics. Anticipating the changes in insurance coverage measurement, we conducted the following webinar in 2014.
- “Measuring Health Insurance Coverage: Improvements and New Opportunities in the Current Population Survey”
The Current Population Survey (CPS), a household survey conducted jointly by the U.S. Census Bureau and the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), is a primary source of economic and labor market data for the U.S. population. Because CPS’s Annual Social and Economic Supplement (ASEC) has collected data about health insurance coverage every year since the 1980s, the CPS has become a rich resource for health services researchers tracking coverage trends. Beginning with the 2014 ASEC (which is administered in February, March and April of 2014 and asks questions about coverage during the calendar year 2013), the Census Bureau implemented a redesign of the health insurance questions to provide more precise measures of coverage. Among other changes, the new method captures current health insurance coverage in addition to coverage on a monthly basis since the beginning of the previous calendar year.This webinar discussed the use of CPS data for applied policy research and explored the survey redesign. Kathleen Adams, Emory University, and Patricia Ketsche, Georgia State University, discussed how they are using CPS data in their current HCFO-funded project and the issues the survey redesign raises for this type of research. Following their presentation, Joanne Pascale from the U.S. Census Bureau provided an overview of the CPS, explained the changes in detail, and discussed both the opportunities and potential challenges the redesign creates for researchers. The webinar recording can be accessed online.
Informing Policymakers and Other Key Constituents
Grantee Briefings
A HCFO activity lauded by both researchers and policymakers is the grantee briefing. The briefings are designed to ensure that policymakers are aware of important research, even before those studies are published. Policymakers are invited to an “early look” at evidence that can help inform their decision-making. The grantees receive feedback from attendees on future analyses and ways to strengthen manuscripts, particularly around implications of study findings for policy and practice. The briefings also serve as a connection point, identifying the “go-to” experts for policymakers on various topics.
In 2014, three HCFO grantees participated in briefings:
- Carrie Colla, Ph.D., Examining the Choosing Wisely List of Test and Treatments with Uncertain or Low Value as a Way to Reduce Waste in the U.S. Health Care System, January 27, 2014
- Matthew L. Maciejewski, Ph.D. and Lesley Curtis, Ph.D., Creating Quality Improvement Opportunities for Medicare Beneficiaries by Linking Lab Values to Claims Data, September 9, 2014
- Kathleen Carey, Ph.D., Examining Intended and Unintended Consequences of the Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program, September 23, 2014
Policy Briefings
For research of particular relevance to specific federal agencies, AcademyHealth staff facilitate policy briefings, or meetings for HCFO researchers with policymakers at their offices to present findings from recently completed studies. These face-to-face meetings are an effective means of sharing study findings with policy audiences, as well as helping grantees broaden their connections with research end-users. This year, two grantees met with staff from CMS, GAO, FTC, CBO, CMS, ASPE, CRS and ONC.
Andrew Ryan, Ph.D., Weill Cornell Medical College, presented findings from his study evaluating the effects of the Medicare Hospital Value-Based Purchasing Program on quality of care during the program’s first year of implementation. June 14, 2014.
R. Adams Dudley, Ph.D., UCSF, presented findings from his study examining the processes and quality of care provided by virtual physician websites for minor acute illnesses. December 4, 2014.
Study Snapshots
In an effort to make findings from HCFO-funded projects more accessible to our policy audience, we launched the “Study Snapshot” publication series. These one-page documents capture the key findings from a study and describe the most important complexities of the research and implications for policy. We released seven Snapshots in 2014:
- Understanding the Tax Burden of Financing Medicaid with a Matching Grant, February 2014
- Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program Prompts Action, Reveals Challenges, April 2014
- Challenges in Achieving Successful Pay-for-Performance Programs, June 2014
- Assessing the Influence of Medical Group Practice Characteristics on Reducing Inappropriate Emergency Department and Avoidable Hospitalization Rates, August 2014
- Assessing the Impact of Hospital Value-Based Purchasing on Clinical Quality and Patient Experience, October 2014
- Insurance Transitions Undermine Children’s Access to Care, November 2014
- The Prevalence and Price of Low-Value Services: Making the Wise Choice, December 2014
HCFO Findings Briefs
In addition to the Snapshots, HCFO staff publishes Findings Briefs, which are designed to reach a broad range of audiences. In this publication, staff summarizes the work of a grantee and discusses important policy implications of the study findings. In 2014, we produced the following five briefs:
- Reducing Inappropriate Emergency Department and Avoidable Hospitalization Rates: Assessing the Influence of Medical Group Practice Characteristics, February 2014
- The Challenges in Achieving Successful P4P Programs, March 2014
- Physicians’ and Hospitals’ Varied Responses to Changes in Medicare Payment: Findings from HCFO Research, August 2014
- The Impact of Tiered Physician Networks on Patient Choices, September 2014
- How Prevalent and Costly are Choosing Wisely Low-Value Services? Evidence from Medicare Beneficiaries, October 2014
In an effort to help develop the next generation of health policy analysts and health services researchers, HCFO collaborated with the George Washington University Department of Health Policy to offer an experiential learning opportunity for one of their M.P.H. students. For her project, Julie Saha, M.P.H., drafted a policy brief that highlights findings from HCFO-funded research on physician and hospital responses to changes to Medicare payment.
- Physicians’ and Hospitals’ Varied Responses to Change in Medicare Payment: Findings from HCFO Research, August 2014
Grantee Publications
The high quality of HCFO grantees’ work is most clearly demonstrated in their peer-reviewed publications. In 2014, grantees published 16 articles in a variety of journals.
- Adams, E.K., et al., Who Really Pays for Medicaid: Intended and Unintended Consequences of the Matching Grant, Public Finance Review, January 2014
- Morden, N.E., et al., Choosing Wisely — The Politics and Economics of Labeling Low-Value Services, NEJM, January 2014
- Maciejewski, M.L., et al., Value-Based Insurance Design Program in North Carolina Increased Medication Adherence But Was Not Cost Neutral, Health Affairs, February 2014
- Choudhry, N.K., et al., Five Features Of Value-Based Insurance Design Plans Were Associated With Higher Rates Of Medication Adherence, Health Affairs, February 2014
- Schpero, W.L., Limiting Low-Value Care by “Choosing Wisely,” Virtual Mentor: American Medical Association Journal of Ethics, February 2014
- Reschovsky, J., Does Location Determine Medical Practice Patterns?, Virtual Mentor: American Medical Association Journal of Ethics, February 2014
- Buchmueller, T., et al., Stability of children’s insurance coverage and implications for access to care: Evidence from the Survey of Income and Program Participation, Int J Health Care Finance Econ, February 2014
- Sinaiko, A.D. and Rosenthal, M.B., The Impact of Tiered Physician Networks on Patient Choices, Health Services Research, March 2014
- Kralewski, J., et al., Do Integrated Health Care Systems Provide Lower-Cost, Higher-Quality Care?, The Journal of the Academy of Physician Executives, March/April 2014
- DeJong, C., et al., Websites that Offer Care Over the Internet: Is There an Access Quality Tradeoff?, JAMA, April 2014
- Ryan, A.M., et al., The Early Effects of Medicare's Mandatory Hospital Pay-for-Performance Program, Health Services Research, July 2014
- Danis, M., et al., A decision exercise to engage cancer patients and families in Deliberation about Medicare Coverage for advanced Cancer Care, Health Services Research, July 2014
- Colla, C.H., et al., Use of non-indicated cardiac testing in low-risk patients: Choosing Wisely, BMJ Quality & Safety, August 2014
- Morden, N.E., et al., Overuse of short-interval bone densitometry: assessing rates of low-value care, Osteoporosis International, September 2014
- Colla, C.H., Swimming against the Current — What Might Work to Reduce Low-Value Care?, NEJM, October 2014
- Colla, C.H, et al., Choosing Wisely: Prevalence and Correlates of Low-Value Health Care Services in the United States, Journal of General Internal Medicine, November 2014
A Successful 25 Years
For the last 25 years, HCFO staff have worked diligently to support the best in health care financing and organization research. HCFO has been recognized as an objective, rigorous investigator-initiated grantmaking program that excels in identifying and supporting research that is useful and used by policymakers. In 2015, HCFO staff look forward to supporting the dissemination and convening activities of our final grantees and documenting the tremendous impact and legacy of the HCFO program on health policy and health services research.